Adaptogens Menopause

What to Know First

Adaptogens in menopause may seem like another new wellness trend, but looking to plants for health and healing is anything but new.

Long before we had a supplement aisle filled with bottles, powders, and capsules, people looked to the plants growing around them. Herbs were grown in gardens, gathered from the surrounding landscape, steeped into teas, added to foods, infused into oils, and passed down through generations as part of everyday life.

Somewhere along the way, many of us became disconnected from that knowledge. Now we’re beginning to look back.

Returning to Plant-Based Wellness

Plant-based wellness can start surprisingly close to home. Your kitchen may already contain herbs and spices traditionally used for health and well-being. A garden can provide another opportunity to learn about the plants that have been valued for generations.

A plant can be traditional and still have side effects. An herb can be natural and still interact with medication. A supplement can contain a familiar plant but provide it in a concentration very different from what you’d get in a cup of tea.

This becomes especially important when looking at adaptogens in menopause. When your body suddenly seems to be playing by a different set of rules, the idea of taking an herb that may help it better adapt to stress sounds promising. Adaptogens are frequently marketed for stress, fatigue, sleep, brain fog, mood, and other concerns that can become more noticeable during the menopause transition.

But adaptogens aren’t magic, and they aren’t automatically safe simply because they come from plants.

So before adding another powder to your smoothie or adding another supplement to your cabinet, let’s look at what adaptogens actually are, what we know about using them during menopause, and where a little extra caution is warranted.

What Are Adaptogens?

Adaptogens are plants and herbs traditionally used to help the body respond to physical and emotional stress. Many have been used for generations in traditional healing systems, including Ayurvedic medicine and Traditional Chinese Medicine. Today, you’ll find them in capsules, powders, teas, tinctures, drinks, and plenty of products marketed specifically for menopause.

Here’s where things get a little tricky.

Calling something an adaptogen doesn’t mean it has been proven to treat menopause symptoms. Research on herbs can be complicated because one study may use a specific standardized extract at a particular dose. At the same time, the supplement you pick up at the store may contain something quite different.

Studies can also be small or short-term, and much of the research on adaptogens looks at general stress, sleep, or fatigue rather than menopause specifically.

That doesn’t mean these herbs have nothing to offer. It simply means it’s important to separate traditional use, promising research, personal experiences, and good marketing from solid evidence.

Not Every Menopause Herb Is an Adaptogen

The words herbal and adaptogen are sometimes used as though they mean the same thing.

They don’t.

Ashwagandha and rhodiola are probably two of the best-known adaptogens. Astragalus and maca are also commonly included in conversations about adaptogens.

Black cohosh is different.

While it’s one of the most recognizable herbs associated with menopause, it isn’t generally classified as an adaptogen. It’s a botanical that has traditionally been used for menopause symptoms, particularly hot flashes and night sweats.

Let’s look at each one.

Ashwagandha: Stress and Sleep

Ashwagandha, sometimes called Indian ginseng, has a long history of use in Ayurvedic medicine.
Today, you’ll see it promoted for just about everything—stress, sleep, mood, anxiety, energy, libido, and even “hormone balance.”

For someone going through menopause, that list can sound pretty tempting. Stress and poor sleep can make fatigue, irritability, brain fog, and even hot flashes feel worse. There is some research supporting the use of ashwagandha for stress and sleep in adults.

There isn’t strong evidence showing that it treats hot flashes, balances hormones, regulates metabolism, improves libido, or treats depression or anxiety specifically during menopause.
Some people may notice that they feel calmer or sleep better while taking it. That’s valuable information for the individual, but personal experience isn’t evidence that an herb will work for everyone.

Ashwagandha Safety

This is one of those places where “natural” doesn’t necessarily mean harmless. Rare cases of liver injury have been linked to ashwagandha supplements. It can also interact with medications and may affect thyroid function, blood sugar, blood pressure, the immune system, and sedation.

Talk with your healthcare provider or pharmacist before using ashwagandha, particularly if you:

• Have a thyroid condition or take thyroid medication
• Have an autoimmune condition
• Take medication for blood pressure or diabetes
• Take medication for anxiety, sleep, or seizures
• Have liver disease or abnormal liver tests
• Are preparing for surgery
• Are pregnant or breastfeeding

Rhodiola: Fatigue and Brain Fog

If menopause has left you wondering where your energy—and occasionally your train of thought—went, you’ve probably noticed products promising to help with both.

Unfortunately, there isn’t enough good research to say that rhodiola reliably improves menopause-related brain fog, hot flashes, night sweats, or anxiety.

Again, that doesn’t mean someone can’t feel better while taking it. It means there isn’t enough evidence to promise that you will. There also isn’t enough research to say exactly which product, form, or dose would be best specifically for menopause.

Rhodiola Safety

Rhodiola can cause side effects, including headache, dizziness, insomnia, dry mouth, and increased saliva.

It may also interact with medications, so use extra caution if you take antidepressants, blood-pressure medications, anti-seizure medications, blood thinners, diabetes medications, or stimulants.

If you’re already struggling with menopause-related insomnia, this is worth remembering: something marketed for “energy” may not be what you want keeping you company at 2:00 in the morning.

Astragalus: More About Immune Support

Astragalus has been used for centuries in Traditional Chinese Medicine and is commonly promoted today for immune health, inflammation, energy, and general wellness.

You’ll sometimes see it included on lists of adaptogens for menopause. But there’s an important difference between an herb potentially supporting general wellness and treating menopause symptoms.

That doesn’t mean astragalus doesn’t have a place in herbal medicine. It shouldn’t be presented as a proven menopause treatment.

Astragalus Safety

Because astragalus may affect the immune system, it isn’t appropriate for everyone. Talk with your healthcare provider or pharmacist before using it if you:

• Have an autoimmune condition
• Have received an organ transplant
• Take medications that suppress your immune system
• Take blood thinners
• Take lithium
• Are pregnant or breastfeeding

Maca: Energy, Mood, and Libido

Maca is a root vegetable native to the Andes. You’ll usually find it sold as a powder, capsule, or extract. It has become especially popular for energy, mood, sexual desire, fertility, and “hormone balance.” There’s one misconception worth clearing up right away.

Maca isn’t a natural hormone. It doesn’t replace estrogen, progesterone, or testosterone.

That doesn’t mean maca can’t be discussed with a healthcare provider if low energy, mood changes, or libido are concerns. Just don’t let a supplement label convince you that these symptoms are something you have to treat on your own. They deserve attention too.

What About Black Cohosh?

Black cohosh isn’t technically an adaptogen, but it belongs in this conversation because it comes up so often when talking about herbal support during menopause.

It has also been researched more directly for menopause than many adaptogens.

The problem? The results have been inconsistent.

Some show possible benefits, while others haven’t. Major menopause guidelines don’t currently recommend herbal supplements, including black cohosh, as proven treatments for hot flashes and night sweats.

That doesn’t mean nobody benefits from it. It means we can’t reliably predict who will benefit, which product will work, or what dose will be most effective.

Black Cohosh Safety

Black cohosh can cause stomach upset, cramping, headache, rash, vaginal spotting or bleeding, and other side effects. There have also been rare reports of serious liver injury associated with commercial black cohosh products.

If you’re taking black cohosh and develop yellowing of the skin or eyes, dark urine, severe fatigue, loss of appetite, nausea, vomiting, or pain in the upper-right side of the abdomen, stop taking it and contact a healthcare professional.

Talk with your healthcare provider before using black cohosh if you have liver disease, abnormal liver tests, a history of hormone-sensitive cancer, or take medications that can affect the liver.

Are Adaptogens Better Than Menopause Treatment?

Not necessarily.

One of the problems with the way supplements are sometimes marketed is the idea that there has to be a choice between “natural” and “medical.” There doesn’t.

Natural doesn’t automatically mean safer, and conventional medicine doesn’t mean lifestyle changes and complementary approaches can’t have a place. There can be room for both when they’re used thoughtfully.

For hot flashes and night sweats, hormone therapy remains the most effective treatment for many people who can safely use it. There are also evidence-based nonhormonal options for those who can’t or don’t want to use hormones.

And sometimes the answer isn’t a medication or supplement at all.

Sleep habits, physical activity, nutrition, stress management, alcohol intake, caffeine, and other aspects of daily life may be worth examining, depending on the symptoms you’re experiencing.
This is where individualized care matters.

How to Explore Adaptogens More Safely

If you’re curious about trying adaptogens in menopause, you don’t have to dismiss them completely. It’s simply important to approach them with the same care you would anything else you’re putting into your body.

Start With Your Symptoms

Before buying anything, spend a couple of weeks paying attention to what’s actually bothering you.

Is it sleep?
Fatigue?
Stress?
Brain fog?
Hot flashes?
Low libido?
Mood changes?

Write it down. Track when it happens and what else is going on. It’s much easier to tell whether something is helping when you know where you started.

Review Everything You’re Already Taking

Don’t forget that herbs count. So do teas, tinctures, powders, vitamins, over-the-counter medications, and supplements.

Bring the entire list to your healthcare provider or pharmacist.

A pharmacist can be an especially valuable resource when checking for interactions between herbs, supplements, and prescription medications. Something being available without a prescription doesn’t guarantee that it’s safe for you.

Try One Thing at a Time

This is a simple rule, but it’s an important one. Don’t start several new supplements at once and then try to figure out which one made you feel better—or worse.

Introduce one product at a time.

Continue tracking your symptoms so you can see whether anything actually changes.
If you develop dizziness, headaches, anxiety, insomnia, stomach problems, heart palpitations, a rash, or anything else unusual, you’ll have a much better idea of what might be responsible.

Look for Third-Party Testing

Supplements aren’t regulated in the same way prescription medications are. The FDA doesn’t approve dietary supplements for safety and effectiveness before they’re sold. That’s one reason quality matters.

Look for transparent labeling and independent testing from organizations such as USP or NSF when possible.

Third-party testing doesn’t prove that an adaptogen works. It simply gives you more confidence that what’s inside the bottle matches what’s printed on the label and has been screened for certain contaminants.

Be Careful With Big Promises

Plants and traditional remedies can have a wellness place. So can complementary approaches. But one product probably won’t fix everything. Be skeptical of supplements promising to:

• Balance all your hormones
• Cure menopause
• Replace hormone therapy
• Eliminate hot flashes in a few days
• Heal your thyroid or adrenal glands
• Treat depression or anxiety
• Work for everyone

Your body is more complicated than that. Menopause is a normal transition, but that doesn’t mean you should have to struggle through symptoms that are affecting your quality of life.

Capsules, Powders, Teas, or Tinctures?

Does the form matter? Sometimes—but one form isn’t automatically safer or better. Capsules can make dosing easier. Powders are convenient for smoothies and food. Teas can be a soothing part of your routine, although they may contain different amounts of an herb than the extracts used in research. Tinctures can be convenient and concentrated, but their strength can vary.

More isn’t necessarily better, either. If you and your healthcare provider decide that an herb is worth trying, pay attention to the specific product, extract, concentration, and dose.

The Bottom Line on Adaptogens in Menopause

Adaptogens in menopause are interesting, and some may eventually prove useful for specific symptoms. But the research isn’t there yet.

Ashwagandha, rhodiola, astragalus, and maca don’t currently have strong evidence supporting their use as treatments for menopause itself. Black cohosh has been studied more extensively for menopause symptoms, but the results remain inconsistent.

That doesn’t mean we need to turn away from plants and the knowledge that generations before us relied upon. It means we need to return to that knowledge thoughtfully.

We’ve spent generations moving farther away from some of the plant knowledge that once lived in our kitchens and gardens. There’s value in rediscovering it. Just bring modern knowledge along with you. Nature can offer us a great deal, but using what it provides safely requires respect, caution, and a little research.

If you found something useful here, click like, subscribe to Fabulous at Forty & Beyond, and check out more at INC’s Fabulous at Forty & Beyond – The Menopause Transition page!

*Health and wellness coaches engage in evidence-based, client-centered processes that facilitate and empower clients to develop and achieve self-determined, health and wellness goals. We do not diagnose, interpret medical data, prescribe or de-prescribe, recommend supplements, provide nutrition consultation or create meal plans, provide exercise prescription or instruction, consult and advise, or provide psychological therapeutic interventions or treatment.